Find Bakeries in New Castle, PA

Service Type & ZIP Code

Refine Your Search

New Castle, PA

  • (Default)
    50 mile radius

Type of Cake

Number of Servings

Items Other than Cake

With Delivery

About Decidio

Decidio provides listings of top local Bakeries in New Castle. Find advice and unbiased reviews on bakeries and wedding cakes in the New Castle area when planning for your wedding, corporate event, mitzvah, or private party.

New Castle area Bakeries
are competing
for your business

Choose By:

Reviews and/or Budgets

Type of Cake

Number of Servings

1 pic

Jody s Pantry Catering

New Castle, PA 16101

Jody's Pantry is a full service catering company with over 10 years of innovative, fine-crafted experience. As membe...

View Details

Brusters Real Ice Cream and Cakes

New Castle, PA 16105

Real Ice Cream, Cakes and Pies made on site daily. Also made on site: Waffle cones & bowls, yogurts, sherbets, ices, s...

View Details

Bosley Cake Company

East Palestine, OH 44413

Please contact me for a free cake tasting and in home consultation. We want to make your special day even better by ...

View Details

1 pic


Poland, OH 44514

JonaBella Catering is a full service catering and event planning company with offices NorthEast Ohio. We offer competit...

View Details

1 pic

Clarencedale Cake

Boardman, OH 44512

  • 5 Reviews

Clarencedale Cake is a unique cake and cupcake shop with locations in both Boardman, Ohio, and Sharon, PA. We offer a...

View Details

1 pic


Youngstown, OH 44505

Enjoy is a local cupcakery featuring over 100 flavors of cupcakes. We specialize in from scratch daily made cupcakes usi...

View Details

1 pic

Sugar Showcase

Youngstown, OH 44515

  • 1 Review

For over 40 years we have supplied our customers with not only a Exquisite Centerpiece but also a Delectable dessert. O...

View Details

1 pic

The Cake Baker

Austintown, OH 44515

Youngstown's most affordable specialty and wedding cakes! The Cake Baker caters to exactly what customers want and de...

View Details

Jean Marc Chatellier French Bakery

Pittsburgh, PA 15209

French/American bakery specializing in wedding & occasion cakes, and breakfast & dessert pastries.

View Details

20 pics

Sweet Treats by Jennifer Yeomans Ch...

Freeport, PA 16229

Sweet Treats by Jennifer Yeomans-Christy specializes in wedding cakes, grooms cakes, custom birthday cakes, and decora...

View Details

1 pic

Save The Date Cakes LLC

Pittsburgh, PA 15220

I no longer use this site. Please email me directly or visit my website for information... I only offer custom cakes....

View Details

The Pittsburgh Cookie Company

Midway, PA 15060

Specializing in wedding cookie tables and favors. Custon corporate cookies and hand decorated cookies. Local cakes and c...

View Details

4 pics

Kara Kakes

Bridgeville, PA 15017

Kara Kakes specializes in cakes that fit your personality. We only use the finest and freshest ingredients possible.

View Details

Top 13 results out of 13 Bakeries in the New Castle area, based on proximity.
Advice on finding New Castle Bakeries - Although many New Castle bakeries have a catalog of different cake styles for your review, your baker should be able to custom-design a wedding cake, birthday cake, baby shower cake, or other type cake using your colors, theme, hobby, dress, bouquet, or anything else deemed central to the event as inspiration. For your New Castle wedding cakes, be sure you have decided on how much you are willing to pay per slice to get the cake you want before you begin shopping. Most New Castle bakeries will deliver your cake to the reception or other event location and also have cake toppers for sale or rent as well.